Location pages turn into doorway pages when the only thing that changes from page to page is the town name. Edward Sturm walks through where that line sits in his episode on doorway pages vs. programmatic SEO. It is a short solo episode, about 10 minutes. He reads Google's own policy, a case study and two checklists from other sites, then gives his own rules. I build town pages for local service businesses, so I took notes.
What Google calls a doorway page
Sturm starts with Google's written definition of doorway abuse: sites or pages "created to rank for specific similar search queries." Google's examples include "having multiple domain names or pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page" and "creating substantially similar pages that are closer to search results than a clearly defined browsable hierarchy."
That first example describes a lot of local business sites. A plumber with one office builds dozens of town pages, each one the same text with a different town name, and every page points to the same phone number. Google has a name for that shape.
A reported case: the HVAC company that lost its suburb pages
Sturm read a case study from another SEO site. A regional HVAC company built "hundreds of pages for each suburb it served," with "similar copy with minor location swaps." After Google's March 2024 core update, "over 80% of those doorway pages lost rankings," and organic traffic fell 63% in 30 days.
Recovery "only began after they consolidated the pages into comprehensive location-specific landing pages with unique content and customer reviews per area."
The company is not named, and nobody in the episode showed the data. Treat it as a reported case. It still matches what Google's policy says, and it is the outcome every owner with a stack of name-swap town pages should worry about.
The test: does anything change besides the town name?
This was the most useful part of the episode for me. Sturm says the difference between a good programmatic page and a doorway page is dependency. On a good page, other content changes because of the thing that changes. On a doorway page, "there are no dependencies on the thing that is changing."
His example of a good programmatic site is bookscal.com, a small tool by Marc Lou. On air, an SEO tool showed it ranking for 629 keywords, 81 of them in positions 1 to 3. On each page, the answer and the reading time change with the word count. The page is different because the input is different.
For a town page, Sturm used "HVAC repair in Los Angeles." The page should talk about why air conditioning matters there, how units work in that climate, and the parts of the city the company serves. In his words, "There is a million different things that you can put to make this page unique."
Sturm also read two checklists aloud. If you answer yes to these, your pages are likely doorways.
From the first checklist:
- The page was built only to rank for one keyword or one place.
- It has little or no unique content.
- It sends visitors somewhere else.
- Several pages differ only by keyword or place name.
- Links to those pages are hidden, or are not in the main navigation.
From the second:
- Is the purpose to funnel visitors to the usable part of the site?
- Do the pages copy groupings that already exist on the site, just to catch more searches?
- Do they "exist as an island," hard to reach from the rest of the site?
- Are links to them made only for search engines?
Sturm added his own rule of thumb: "If you are making pages that are so bad that you don't want your normal visitors to see them, that is a red flag right there."
How Sturm says to build them
Sturm's fix is to put these pages under a hub page that real visitors can reach. A page you are "cool with people seeing," one you could "proudly put in your footer navigation."
He made two more points that matter for local businesses:
- Similar searches still need different pages. "Show how your product or service serves this specific keyword instead of just the group of keywords in general."
- Do not target only places. A common mistake, he says, is "no variance in the keywords that you're going after." One phrase times every town is the doorway pattern.
His on-page advice is short:
- Write the keyword as a real phrase. "HVAC repair in Los Angeles," not "HVAC repair Los Angeles," in the H1. He says the fragment version is "seen as spammy. Searchers don't like it. Google doesn't like it." That is his opinion. He did not cite a test.
- Put the phrase in the page title, the meta description, the URL slug, the H1 and the start of the first sentence. Then stop. Do not stuff variations into the subheadings.
His case for doing the work: pages that are unique and useful last. "You are durable. You last for a very long time on Google because you are giving searchers what they want."
What it means for a local business owner
Location pages are fine when each one has a real reason to exist. Look at your own town pages and ask Sturm's question: if I swap the town name, does anything else on the page need to change? If the answer is no, Google's policy describes that page.
Other SEO experts I follow land in the same place. Darren Shaw says to rework every paragraph for each town and group town pages under a hub. David Quaid has described a marketplace that lost most of its traffic for pages that changed only the place.
How we use this at eezyRank
- Each town gets its own town page, built from research on that town, and that town's service pages sit under it. The town pages are reachable from the menu. Nothing is hidden from visitors.
- We build one page for each specific search a buyer types. Each page answers a question people really search for.
- We skip combinations that make no sense. Not every service gets a page in every town.
- We tell owners plainly what town pages can do. They compete in normal search results and AI answers. They do not put a business into the map pack of a town where it has no office.
If you want to see what we build for local service businesses, take a look at https://eezyrank.com.





