How to pick SEO keywords was the question behind a thread that went viral on r/SEO. Edward Sturm read the top comments from that thread on his show and said where he agreed and where he did not. You can hear it in his episode on the Reddit keyword thread. Much of it matches how we pick new page ideas at eezyRank.
The Reddit commenters are not named. Below, "a commenter" means the idea came from the thread and Sturm agreed with it. "Sturm" means he said it himself.
Look at Google, not at a difficulty score
Most SEO tools give each search a difficulty score. Sturm says not to trust it. He says tools often called a search hard, he targeted it properly, ranked first within one or two weeks, and stayed there for years. That is his account. He did not show data for it.
His test is free. Type the search into Google and look at the top results. Count how many of them put the search words in the page title and in the web address. Also check the main heading and the start of the first sentence. If few of the top pages do that, nobody has really built a page for that search, and it is easy.
A commenter added a warning about AI, and Sturm agreed. Do not ask ChatGPT or another assistant how hard a search is unless you give it live search data. Without that, it guesses "in a confident sounding way." Use AI to group searches and spot gaps. Do not use it to judge difficulty.
For a local owner, this means ten minutes in Google can tell you more than a paid tool. One commenter put it as "10 minutes in the results beats an hour in a spreadsheet," and Sturm agreed.
Build the kind of page Google already shows
Before you build anything, look at what kind of pages sit on page one. If they are all product or service pages, Google wants that kind of page. Sturm says different searches need different page types, and the job is to match what the searcher wants. Some searches take a service page. Some take a blog post.
There is an exception, and it is the part I find most useful. Sturm says many high-intent searches have no page made for them, so Google shows the closest match. A blog post may rank only because nobody built the right page. That leaves room for the business that builds it.
He also gives a stop sign. If a search has been targeted a lot and blog posts still beat the sales pages, people do not want to buy on that search. Pick other searches first.
The searches he likes most are the ones where the person knows what they want but not which business gives it to them. He says those "convert at ridiculous degrees." Picture someone who already knows they want their tub replaced with a walk-in shower and is now looking for who does that in their town.
Sturm's order of questions goes like this:
- Who are my competitors?
- What do they rank for without targeting it properly?
- Which of those searches bring money?
- Which results are under-targeted, using the title and web address test?
- Then sort by search volume.
Volume comes last on his list, not first. A commenter also said competitor research is a good place to start: see what they rank for and what they target badly. Sturm agreed.
Start with what Search Console already shows
Google Search Console is free, and it lists the searches your site already shows up for. A commenter said to start there before any tool, and Sturm agreed. Searches where you sit on page 5 or 6 that you never targeted are, in the commenter's words, "Google telling you what it thinks you are." Moving a page from spot 50 to spot 20 is easier than starting from nothing.
Another commenter said the best chances are often searches where you already sit at spots 5 to 20. Sturm called it "a great comment."
Sturm's quick win: take the searches a page already shows for and put those words high up on that page. He points to an earlier episode of his on this, number 1,014.
For a local owner, this is the cheapest SEO work there is. You are not building anything new. You are telling Google more clearly what a page you already have is about.
Group searches, then give each group one page
A commenter said to group searches by meaning, then give each group one page, instead of treating every search as its own target. Sturm agreed.
The same thread suggested one main search per page, plus one or two related searches for context. The rest become blog posts or FAQs. Sturm agreed with the shape but not the order. He says pick the search first, then decide the right page. Do not start with a page and hunt for searches to fit it.
When a search needs a new page, Sturm says to put it in four places: the title, the web address, the main heading, and the start of the first sentence. He has said the same in earlier episodes.
One more caution from him. "How to" and "what is" articles can rank and still bring no money. They can help if they link to your sales pages, because they can pass some of their authority along. My own read: a plumber with ten articles about how drains work and no page for drain cleaning in their town has the order backwards.
Sturm also mentions his course, Compact Keywords, in the episode.
How we use this at eezyRank
We build pages around the specific searches buyers type. One example: 1,728 pages for one Florida bath remodeler, each built around one specific search.
For clients with Google Boost turned on, we read their Search Console on a regular schedule. Pages that already show for a search, but not near the top, get a short added section aimed at that search. That is close to Sturm's quick win, done on a schedule.
Searches that no page covers yet become new page ideas. Before an idea goes on the list, we look at what Google already shows for it, much like Sturm's check. The easier wins go first, and each idea gets the kind of page Google already favors for that search.
To see what eezyRank builds for local businesses, take a look at https://eezyrank.com.





